Hi Trish & Rino:

This is a wonderful song.  It's obvious that a good deal of care and planning went into the creation of this composition/arrangement.

And Trish, your thoughtful words are so apropos.

I'll leave it there guys...

Griff

The idea to combine your piano play with hardrock elements is not bad

but to be honest I don´t think the  sound mix is too great. The drums could

sound more like natural rock drums. Temporarily  some instruments are

way too loud. The piano should have more space in the mix. Sorry.

Hallo!

Ich schreibe auf deutsch:

Ich muss hier leider Ize recht geben, der Sound der Drums ist sehr synthetisch und nervt auf Dauer.

Teilweise ist die Snare auch etwas zu laut und verzerrt.

Die Idee an sich ist aber spitze und euren Spaß bei der Sache hört man.

Mir hat's gefallen. 4* ++++

Liebe Grüße

MuggeMaker

What a a big surprise !!
Trish in Rock with Rino ..really a great and pleasant surprise for me .. and with music of great impact rock prog..very beautiful ..I like it a lot ..a Ilke also the music-idea very interesting ...
Two great friends, with a great composition !!
A big embrace From
Antonio Fiorillo ♥♥♥♥♥

Trish the rock chick escapes the chains of her respectable teacher persona, with a little help from Rino - and to deserved public acclaim.  There are and have been some great collaborations going on recently (well OK I've only been here since recently, so this may be the norm, but I wouldn't know).  This definitely rates as an extremely successful one and one in which both parties seem to have adapted their natural style to create something new.  How cool is that?

Many congratulations to both of you.  Seems to me there is a precendent set now for future such melding of minds with you two immensely talented chappies ( a lady can be a chappy in my world - really Trish).

Well done, bravi Trish and Rino, lovely and beautiful music.

A big hello to you both, Diego

Hi Trish & Rino:

There is one caveat that I Would like to raise.  Although this is (without doubt) a marvelous work by both Trish and Rino, I would caution those who participate in future collaborations to be aware of the perils of mixing down delicate piano phrasings (especially when accompanied by drums, horns, bass, or other naturally voluminous instruments).

I have listened to this delightful song several times and have noticed that Trish's piano is quite faint.  The volume definitely has to be augmented during her pianistic phrasings.  As it stands, I had to turn up the volume in order to obtain the full effects of the piano (which of course, also enhanced the volume of the other instruments).  Not an ideal situation (to say the least).

As I mentioned in my previous comments, Trish and Rino has produced a stellar musical presentation, but a little re-mixing (if possible) would give this sound the fuller dimension that it so richly deserves.

This is just my personal assessment.  I hope that it is taken in the 'constructive' spirit in which it was intended.

Griff

A me sembra un buon lavoro, un poco originale, ma molto buono, e se nessuno tentasse di percorre nuove strade saremmo ancora ai tempi del minuetto, bravi  a tutte e due, 5* da tgfmusica, Gianfranco, ciao

I rarely like to comment on my own (or partially my own)  songs but I want to make certain that everyone is aware that all comments are heartily welcomed..  I, and I am sure Rino, take no offense at constructive criticisms.  I feel that constructive comments are what improves a musician's future compositions and I would hope others feel the same way.

There is a great degree of likes and dislikes as far as music is concerned so of course there will be a variety of comments, some good and some not so good.  I feel that if the listener offers suggestions on how to improve, especially on collaborations, that they have actually listened to the song with a keen ear and without preconceived notions.  

So I thank you all for your comments, suggestions and thoughts pertaining to this collaboration .

Trish

Hi! marshallt2, Heuno, Rino.. Sinnbildlich gesehen passte für mich alles. Die Sensibelchen störten mich nicht. Ihr habt es doch gut gemacht.

LG / aces-e37

a collaboration I always find very interesting.

the result of it I really like. The soulful keys of trish and rock bkgrnd of rino.

very good work

en liebe gruess vom

sandro

this new partnership, which had long been expecting it because the heuno friend, had warned me that it was nearing completion the song.
I would call this track a symphonic rock, all seems well defined, and the sounds are very light and melodic.
not the rock that I prefer, but the quality is not discussed, so my opinion is positive, I would say that the collaboration is successful

franco

Hey Trish, Rino hey ... that's not so easy to please or to deal with reviewers .... I know about your and your Trish can ... but it is missing the song of deep, to sound ... of soul .... is presented very vividly ... without deep - without heart ... may be that you see the different .... but then this represents for me ... it's too little soul, as I could make star because ... I feel what you want ... but you have not reached all ... brave .... but sorry greetings to you all ... Andi

Bravissimi un bel lavoro mi piace moltisimo cioa Pino

A song of this complexity is hard to handle with regard to the mastering. Now, you are both rather composers or instrumentalists than sound-engeneers - and so this song, which surely is a good song, would need a final mastering to really reach the audience. The performance itself is fine, but there is much more possible with this track, I think. You see, I can only accompany to what Griff says below: I guess he's right, there is far more potential in this song than this version can show.

Hi Trish/Rino!

The song is good but Andi,Griff and Thomas have right. The mastering goes better. :-) It is not a critic to your playing or a critic on this idea. Andi say´s, for this moment is without a soul. Please, make this song again, with better mastering! I know, to master a song is very heavy and from time to time, I have the same problems, but I test a many and find the right one. A little more time and patient and then it gives a good result of a hard work, ok? But hey, it is a good collaboration, without doubt. For the idea it gives 3 Stars from me. Thank you for send the song!

regards Bernd

Tolle Musik von Euch,gefällt mir.

Mir persönlich gefällt die snare nicht so aber ist wohl geschmacksache.

Tolles Klavier Trish

Liebe grüße an euch beide.

Orlando

Hallo ihr beiden,

hier glaube ich auch , das noch etwas Luft nach oben ist !

Den Sound finde ich persönlich echt gut , hätte aber  vieleicht noch so ein paar Pads in den backround geschickt die das ganze zum fließen bringen !

Ansonsten ist es aber ein hörenswerter Track und nicht umsonst die ganze Arbeit .

LG

Jojo

penso che il brano sia molto bell. rock progressive? comunque piacevole all'ascolto. wrong mixer? non importa, il missaggio non è una cosa facile. comunque qui si valutano soprattutto le idee, altrimenti se tutto fosse perfetto credo che non verrebbe pubblicato in magix comunity, ma altrove, in sedi molto più qualificate. Quindi penso che l'idea di Rino e Trish sia stata geniale e l ' apprezzo moltissimo. Visto che conosco entrambi da un po' di tempo, posso dire che ascoltando questa musica si sentono distintamente le loro singole anime, le loro differenti interpretazioni di fare musica, e questo secondo me è un gran pregio, ma il tutto viene ben armonizzato in questa meravigliosa composizione. Continuate così ragazzi...siete sulla strada giusta....vi abbraccio entrambi, ma a trish do anche un bacio!

Bravissimi!

Paolo

Excellent work

Very nice track and very good sound .

I like it .

With this piece I and Trish, have tried to offer something original, someone pointed out to us some imperfections in the mix, but I still think that this is a good job.
We thank who made constructive criticism, and we also thank all those who have proven to enjoy our music.

Greetings to all and especially to Trish.

Rino

Interesting collaboration and mixture of genres...

... it wasn't "love at 1st sight" for me... but after listening to the track about 3 times... i really started to like it.

Well done !!!