@ProductionSavard

HI

Song collections are complete finished song compilations ie audio files, used, for example, as backing music to videos or slideshows.

John EB
Forum Moderator

Hi,

Thanks johnebaker for your reply!

Does it mean I could also sell my finished songs on Producer Planet if I bought the commercial license? 

If so, do you know how I can do this?

@ProductionSavard I believe most Song Collections from Magix are the Soundpool demo songs, but as an audio file, not as loop pack. It's simply stock music.

No, you can't sell your music on Producerplanet.com

Hi!
Thanks for your reply!

Well, it anwser my questions, it's clearly not for me, i can do my own songs haha & that's a shame they can sell their songs but we can't sell ours hahaha.

Fortunately there are plenty of other ways to sell our songs with the commercial licence, but it's still a shame since the goal is to encourage each other as Audio Producers, on a producer website.

Thanks again, and have a nice day!

@ProductionSavard

Hi,

Well, it anwser my questions, it's clearly not for me, i can do my own songs haha & that's a shame they can sell their songs but we can't sell ours hahaha.

For any songs that are actually built from the Soundpools/loops, "They" actually happen to be the copyright holder of the Soundpool/loops. You are not. "They" created the loops, you did not.

As well, if you create a song using the Soundpool loops, you can sell it so long as you have a Commercial Use license for the Soundpool containing the loops used and you follow whatever is indicated in the license. However, you may find that many commercial distributors will not accept loop-based songs. After all, you didn't actually create anything, you just strung a bunch of loops together created by others, and anyone can do that, including repeating exactly what you do.

Furthermore, even with a Commercial Use license, the license does not give you exclusivity and you do not hold the copyright to the loops. Thus, you cannot stop me or anyone else from purchasing and using the same loops.

Does it mean I could also sell my finished songs on Producer Planet if I bought the commercial license?

Perhaps to explain better the reply from @SP., you probably could sell your songs on ProducerPlanet but you have to go through Magix, sign a contract, follow the rules, etc. You cannot just upload songs and hope to sell them. If you have original productions, original music, not just loop-based songs using loops created by others, then contact Magix.

Here is a listing of the labels that sell Loops & Samples and Songs on Producer Planet:

Note that there are only 3 that sell songs on Producer Planet, including Magix.

John CB

you’re right, i only strung a bunch of loop together, it’s still a nice start for a new producer who wants to learn further things to maie my own sounds. Don’t worry, i have the commercial license. And i don’t want to make my life more complicated just to sell on Producer Planet. It was only a question like that, as i will be published on the majority of streaming app for musics with Distrokid, awesome company! I recommend them! Low cost, easy setup and you keep 100% of what you make.

"After all, you didn't actually create anything, you just strung a bunch of loops together created by others, and anyone can do that, including repeating exactly what you do."

Yep DJ Shadow, Prince Paul, Dust Brothers, Madlib, MF Doom, etc just strung a bunch of samples together created by others and anyone can do that!! Not everyone can string loops, samples together and make a decent beat, etc. I personally think you gotta have at least a decent ear for this sort of thing. Go check out producer planet and listen to some of the "Music" on there and tell me that "anyone can string loops together" Plus whats the chances of someone making the exact same beat as you at the same tempo, pitch,etc.

Yeeeeep!

and i did a lot of song before its get even a bit listenable. HAHA. Like you said, nothing else to add, you are completely right!
 

It took me a complet month to make a decent beat, if never you wanna ear it. It is some Ambient Trap/Hip Hop : https://on.soundcloud.com/vbFvuKiiPxMAzsE1A

@ProductionSavard I only started doing this in May last year and its only the last few months or so ive become halfway decent. So for anyone to say, anyone can string loops together etc and make a beat is a bit ignorant. Like i said, go listen to some of the "music" on producer planet and tell me that anyone can do it.

Yeah i know hahaha i don’t really mind about those who criticize other even if they are right or just a lot better. Toxic people will always still toxic in everything they’re doing.
 

And yeah i know producer planet that's where i found the perfect loop bundle for me. I couldn’t wait for the price reduction, i took the royalty free license for 60$ and i could make 5 songs that I’ll gladly stream everywhere i can with Distrikid 🫶🏻